Preliminary Study on Tissue Culture Technique of Brassica campestris L.ssp.chinensis(L.)Makino var.utilis

Yanchun QIAO, Hongdi HUANG, Hua ZHANG, Guangguang LI, Yansong ZHENG, Zizhu LIU

Guangzhou Academy of Agricultural Sciences, Guangzhou 510308, China

Brassica campestris L.ssp. chinensis var. utilis is one of the specialty vegetables in South China. It has been cultivated in Guangdong and Guangxi for a long time. The variety resources were very abundant[1]. Currently, conventionality breeding is mainly adopted in the breeding of Brassica campestris L.ssp. chinensis var. utilis. Because the period of conventionality breeding is long and the efficiency is low, and conventionality breeding is affected by apparent growth status, elite varieties are hardly to be bred.Moreover,in the aspect of disease resistance breeding,the weakness of conventionality breeding is more obvious. Because disease resistance characters are hardly to be maintained in progenies, the relative index parameters of disease resistance are hardly to be confirmed.Haploid plants of more than 50 kinds of plants have been obtained by haploid breeding since which was applied in 1970s[2]. Regeneration plants of multiple Cruciferae crops were obtained through anther culture or microspore culture.The Cruciferae crops included Brassica campestris[3], B. oleracea var. botrytis[4], B. oleracea[5],B. chinensis[6], Raphanus sativus[7],B. rapa ssp.chinensis[8],B.compestris var. purpurea[9], B. alboglabra[10], etc.Currently, there are several reports about the anther culture technique of Brassica campestris L. ssp. chinensis var. utilis but the techniques are not mature and most researches are still stayed at the embryoid phase[11-14].The tissue culture operations vary from person to person and the key tech-niques cannot be copied. This experiment tried to confirm the best period and statue of anther for culture according to the morphology of pollen and anther of Brassica campestris L. ssp.chinensis var. utilis. According to tissue culture, operable technical condition and method of anther tissue culture were quested and scientific basis was also provided for elite variety breeding of Brassica campestris L.ssp.chinensis var.utilis.

Materials and Methods

Materials

Testing materials were taken from Flower base of Guangzhou Academy of Agricultural Science. Thirty two germplasm resources of Brassica campestris L. ssp. chinensis var. utilis were used in the test. Six varieties including 49-19 caixin, Youlv 50 tian,lvbao 70 tian, Youlv 702, Youlv 801 and Chixin caixin 4 were bred by Guangzhou Academy of Agricultural Science. The other 26 materials included four early maturing varieties,six middle maturing varieties, four late maturing varieties, six wide leaf varieties and six gracile leaf varieties. The phenotypes of the testing materials had significant differences, which provided abundant genotypic materials.

Measurement of pollen viability

Pollen viability of Brassica campestris L. ssp. chinensis var. utilis was measured based on the medium germination method of Liu et al[15]. The culture medium was 100 mg/L sucrose+30 mg/L boric acid.

Anther culture

Callus induction Materials with different genotypes were cultured on different media with different levels of growth regulators for callus induction.The basic medium was MS with the addition of 3% sugar, 6 g/L agar and 8% coconut milk. KT and 2, 4-D were used as growth regulators. The dosage of growth regulators were screened through simple factor design of experiment. The dosages of KT were set as 0.5,1.0 and 2.0 mg/L,and the dosages of 2, 4-D were set as 1.0 and 2.0 mg/L.

Differentiation culture of bud Tight calluses were inoculated on culture media for the differentiation of adventitious bud. MS+ 2% sucrose+ 6 g/L agar was used as the basic culture medium. Additives and the combination of growth regulators were screened by double-factor design(Table 1).Thirty calluses were cultured on each medium.

Table 1 Selection of bud differentiation medium for Brassica campestris ssp.chinensis var.utilis

Tissue culture of cotyledon-cotyledonary petioles

Preparation of materials and induction of callus Seeds of Brassica campestris L. ssp. chinensis var. utilis(49 -19 Caixin) were sterilized with 70% ethyl alcohol for 30 s and 0.1%mercury bichloride for 6-8 min, and cultured on MS media under dark for about 15 d. The cotyledon-cotyle-donary petioles were selected as explants and cultured on media for callus induction. The culture media were MS+1.0 mg/L KT + 1.0 mg/L 2, 4-D +3% sugar + 6 g/L agar + 8% coconut milk. Three explants were inoculated in each bottle and the experiment was repeated three times. Induction rates of calluses were counted after 15 d dark culture.

Induction of adventitious buds

Cotyledon-cotyledonary petiole callus were inoculated on induction media for adventitious buds. The media were MS+2.0 mg/L 6-BA+0.5 mg/L NAA+1.0 g/L activated carbon+2%sugar +6 g/L agar or MS + 2.0 mg/L ZT + 0.5 mg/L IAA + 0.5 g/L AgNO3+ 1.0 g/L activated carbon + 2% sugar + 6 g/L agar. Each treatment were inoculated for ten bottles and repeated three times. Induction ratios of adventitious buds were counted after 15 d light culture.

Rooting culture The induced adventitious buds were transformed on rooting culture media (1/4 MS or 1/8 MS+0.1 mg/L IBA+2%sugar+6 g/L agar). The induced adventitious buds were inoculated for ten bottles with two plants each bottle and three replicates.Rooting situation was observed after 15 d light culture.

Results and Analysis

Pollen morphology of Brassica campestris L. ssp. chinensis var.utilis at mid-late uninucleate stage

For anther and pollen culture,development stage of pollen is very important for the improvement of plant regeneration rate. Identifying the development stage of pollen accurately and inoculating pollens appropriately are key operation techniques of anther and pollen culture.Development stage of pollens was observed and confirmed with microscope. Pollens at mid-late uninucleate stage were mainly selected for anther culture. At the mid-late uninucleate stage, flowers were not bloom and flower stigmas were slightly higher than petals, and most pollen cells were haploid or diploid and polyploidy doubled naturally(Fig.1).

Pollen viability

Pollen viability was measured with germination method to determine the stage of strong viability. It could be seen from Table 2 that the samples were harvested on September 7 and November 15, 2012, respectively, and the germination rates of Brassica campestris L. ssp. chinensis var. utilis were at a middle level, which illustrated that pollen viability of the tested materials were general. The germination rate of pollens harvested on September 7,2012 was slightly higher than 50% after germinated for 4 h while the germination rate of pollens harvested on November 15, 2012 could reach 70%,which illustrated that at the most suitable growth stage of Brassica campestris L. ssp. chinensis var. utilis, November, pollen viability was relatively stronger and pollens were more suitable for pollen culture.Elliptical pollens were closely dotted on the inoculated culture media (Fig.2 A). Small protuberances occurred on the edge of the elliptical pollens after which were cultured at 25 ℃for 2 h(Fig.2B). The small protuberances elongated gradually after the pollens cultured for 4 h and types of the pollens looked like small tadpoles (Fig.2C), thus this stage was the most suitable stage for the statistics of pollen germination condition.The germinated long pollen tubes intertwined together after cultured for 8 h, which was not conducive for the statistics of pollen germination rate.

Bud differentiation and induction of anther callus

Induction rate of anther callus was observed and counted. The results showed that calluses induced on MS+1.0 mg/L KT + 1.0 mg/L 2, 4-D + 3%sugar + 6 g/L agar + 8% coconut milk were tightness that the culture medium was suitable for callus induction.MS+2.0 mg/L 6-BA + 0.5 mg/L NAA + 1.0 g/L activated carbon+2%sugar+6 g/L agar or MS + 2.0 mg/L ZT + 0.5 mg/L IAA+0.5 g/L AgNO3+1.0 g/L activated carbon + 2% sugar + 6 g/L agar were suitable for the induction of adventitious buds(Table 1,differentiation rate was 36.7%). During the culture process,calluses induced with anthers of Brassica campestris L.ssp.chinensis var. utilis were found to be easily differentiated and there were many trichomes appeared (Fig.3). After the tight calluses were transformed to differential media, calluses turned green and there were many small buds generated but only several bud points could differentiate young buds (Fig.4).Browning phenomenon became severer with the growth of young buds.The browning condition cannot be improved though Vc was added to the culture media.The phenomenon might be resulted from autotoxicity of the materials that the young buds cannot be further differentiated and then they browned to death.

Table 2 Pollen germination rate(%)of Brassica campestris ssp.chinensis var.utilis

Explant culture and establishment of regeneration system

The differentiation rates of buds generated from calluses through anther induction were low and the differ-entiation qualities were bad. Cotyledon-cotyledonary petioles were used as explants in this study for tissue culture and plant regeneration, thus to provide ideas for the improvement of bud differentiation rate by anther culture.The results showed that most explant tissues directly differentiated into adventitious buds without callus stage(Fig.5A, B) when cotyledon-cotyledonary petioles of Brassica campestris L. ssp. chinensis var. utilis were used for tissue culture.The induction rate of adventitious buds reached 85% and the speed of bud multiplication was fast. The well developing adventitious buds were transformed to rooting media, 1/4MS or 1/8MS +0.1 mg/L IBA +2% sugar + 6 g/L agar, thus to obtain intact plants (Fig.5C) and the rooting rate reached 80%. It could be seen that, using cotyledon-cotyledonary petioles as explants to directly differentiate adventitious buds might be a characteristic of Brassica campestris L. ssp. chinensis var. utilis whereas obtaining regeneration plants through calluses obtained from anther culture was had. The future research thought should be further adjusted.

Discussions

Inbreeding of more generation needed in conventional cross-breeding due to the segregation of genetic characters is leaved out when anther and pollen culture were adopted to breed haploid or homozygous diploid plants.Moreover, the haploid or homozygous diploid plants can be used as inbred lines for the utilization of heterosis and the breeding cycle is greatly shortened that it is always a research emphasis of breeding workers[16]. Anther culture and pollen culture of Brassicaceous vegetables has been deeply studied,such as Chinese cabbage, B. pekinensis, B. oleracea var. gemmifera,B. oleracea var. capitata, B. oleracea var. botrytis, broccoli, B. juncea and B. rapa, and some studies has been applied in breeding practice[17].Though anther culture and pollen culture of Brassica campestris L. ssp. chinensis var. utilis has been reported, the technology is still immature.Fujian Institute of Agricultural Sciences once studied the technology of pollen culture of Brassica campestris L. ssp. chinensis var.utilis but there was no report about it. Xiao et al. observed the microsporogenesis and male gametophyte development of Brassica campestris L.ssp. chinensis var. utilis[18]. Professor Feng in Shenyang Agricultural University studied the techniques for microspore culture of most Brassicaceous vegetables, but the techniques were immature and needed to be further studied[12].

The results in this study indicated that not bloomed flower bud and higher flower stigmas than petals were the morphological characteristics of Brassica campestris L. ssp. chinensis var.utilis pollen at mid-late uninucleate stage. The germination rates of pollens in autumn and winter were higher than that in summer.The culture medium for callus induction of Brassica campestris L. ssp. chinensis var. utilis anther was MS + 1.0 mg/L KT + 1.0 mg/L 2,4-D+3%sugar+6 g/L agar+8% coconut milk. Differentiation media of adventitious bud were MS + 2.0 mg/L 6-BA + 0.5 mg/L NAA + 1.0g/L activated carbon + 2% sugar + 6 g/L agar or MS + 2.0 mg/L ZT + 0.5 mg/L IAA+0.5 g/L AgNO3+1.0 g/L activated carbon + 2% sugar + 6 g/L agar.The induction rate of adventitious buds obtained from anther culture was 36.7% and the induction rate was not improved when exogenous BR and TDZ were added. The regeneration rate of plants obtained with cotyledoncotyledonary petioles as explants reached 80%.The rooting media were 1/4 MS or 1/8MS+0.1 mg/L IBA+2%sugar+6 g/L agar.In the research,intact regeneration plants were obtained by cotyledon-cotyledonary petiole culture but not anther culture. Adventitious buds were directly differentiated without callus stage, which was a characteristic of the tissue culture of Brassica campestris L. ssp. chinensis var.utilis[19].It can be seen that to obtain diploid plants of Brassica campestris L. ssp. chinensis var. utilis through anther culture is difficult.

Anther culture is not only affected by culture medium and growth regulatory substances but also affected by environment factors.The growth environment of donor plants is critical for anther and pollen culture, especially temperature and light. Zhang[20]conducted microspore culture of Chinese cabbage at 15-20 ℃with 14-16 h/d light and found that the occurrence rate of embryoids and regeneration rate of plants were high. For anther culture of cauliflower, the anther culture effect of donor plants harvested at 10-20 ℃greenhouse in spring was the best. The materials of Brassica campestris L. ssp. chinensis var. utilis used in this study were grew in field and the most appropriate growth seasons of Brassica campestris L. ssp.chinensis var. utilis were autumn and winter. The illumination time is short during October to December that the pollen viability is not strong enough. It can be seen that anther and pollen culture are affected by the growth environment of donor plants in addition to the culture condition, culture medium and growth regulatory substance.Brassica campestris L. ssp. chinensis var. utilis may be more sensitive to light. Above all, because of the many influence factors of anther and pollen culture, and the more strict culture condition needed by Brassica campestris L.ssp.chinensis var.utilis,how to screen appropriate factors,media and growth regulatory substances for anther and pollen culture,and construct an perfect system for diploid breeding of Brassica campestris L. ssp. chinensis var. utilis needs to be further studied.

[1]LI GG (李光光), ZHANG H (张华),HUANG HD (黄红弟), et al. Research progress on flowering Chinese cabbage breeding in Guangdong Province (广东省菜薹(菜心)育种研究进展) [J]. China Veget(中国蔬菜),2011(20):9-14.

[2]ZHANG L (张丽), WANG J (王静).Progress of haploid breeding in Cruciferae crops(十字花科作物单倍体育种研究进展) [J]. J Anhui Agri Sci(安徽农业科学),2003,31(2):231-234.

[3]KELLER WA, ARMSTRONG KC. Embryogenesis and plant regeneration in Brassica napusanther cultures [J].Can J Bot,1977,55(10):1383-1388.

[4]FARHAM MW, CANIGLIA EJ, THOMAS CE. Efficient ploidy determination of anther-derived broccoli[J].Hort Science,1988,33(2):323-327.

[5]GORECKA K.Obtaining of homozygous lines of head cabbage (Brassica oleracea L. var. capitata L.) with aid of an-ther culture[J].Prace Habilitacyjne,1998(14):1-71.

[6]GENG JF(耿建峰), YUAN YX(原玉香),ZHANG XW (张晓伟),et al.A new Chinese cabbage:Yuyuan 50(利用游离小孢子培养技术育成抗热大白菜新品种豫园) [J]. Acta Hort Sin(园艺学报), 2002,29(1):89.

[7]MEI SY (梅时勇),YANG BG (杨保国),YAO F, (姚芳) et al. Study on anther culture technique of the radish (萝卜花药培养实验) [J].China Veget (中国蔬菜),2002(1):35-36.

[8]FENG H(冯辉),YANG S(杨硕),WANG CN (王超楠), et al. Obtaining and utilization of DH lines in pakchoi(Brassica rapa L.ssp.chinensis L.) (青梗菜优异DH 系的创制与利用)[J].Sci Agri Sin(中国农业科学),2009,42(9):3195-3202.

[9]WANG TT (王涛涛), LI HX (李汉霞),ZHANG JH (张继红),et al.Isolated microspore culture and plant regenerationin purple fl owering stalk (Brassica compestris ssp. chinensis var. pupurea Hort.)(红菜薹游离小孢子培养与植株再生)[J].J Wuhan Bot Res(武汉植物学研究),2004,22(6):569-571.

[10]HE HJ (何杭军),WANG XW (王晓武),WANG BL (汪炳良). Embryogenesis and plant regeneration of Chinese Kale via isolated microspore culture(芥蓝游离小孢子培养初报)[J]. Acta Hort Sin(园艺学报),2004,31(2):239-240.

[11]ZHU YH(朱允华),LIU Q(刘清),WU CL(吴朝林), et al. Study on embryoid induction of Brassica parachinensis Bailey anther culture (菜薹花药培养诱导胚状体的研究)[J].Biotechn Bull (生物技术通报),2008(2):136-139.

[12]LIU RE (刘如娥).Research on the anther culture techniques for several vegetable crops in Brassica campestris(芸薹属芸薹种几种主要蔬菜作物花药培养技术研究) [D]. Shenyang:Shenyang Agricultural University(沈阳:沈阳农业大学),2008:8-65.

[13]WU YF (吴艺飞),DING ZY (丁茁荑),XIAO J (肖杰), et al. Affecting factors for embryo rate of anther culture of flowering Chinese cabbage (菜薹花药培养出胚率的影响因素研究)[J]. Hunan Agri Sci (湖南农业科学),2012(7):8-11.

[14]LIU SH (刘胜洪),ZENG MH (曾慕衡),LIANG H (梁红),et al.Study on some factors of culture of Brassica napus CMS lines and flowering Chinese cabbage hybrid anther(甘蓝型油菜不育系与菜心杂交后代花药培养中若干因素的研究)[J].Crops(作物杂志),2007(3):58-60.

[15]LIU HC(刘会超),JIA WQ(贾文庆),JIA GR(贾国瑞).Studies on pollen viability and storage characteristics of Prunus ceraifera (紫叶李花粉生活力及贮藏特性研究)[J].J Anhui Agri Sci(安徽农业科学),2010,38(9):4507-4508.

[16]GUO JY(郭金英), SHEN SX(申书兴),CHEN XP (陈雪平),et al.Progress of isolated microspore cultures of Cruciferae vegetabale crops (十字花科蔬菜游离小孢子培养研究进展)[J].J Agri Univ Hebei(河北农业大学学报),2002,25(S1.):122-124.

[17]WU J(武剑), GONG YQ(龚义勤), LIU LW (柳李旺),et al.Advances on plantlet induction from pollen of Cruciferae vegetables (十字花科蔬菜花粉植株诱导技术研究进展) [J].J Anhui Agri Sci(安徽农业科学), 2000, 28 (6): 747-749,754.

[18]XIAO XF (肖旭峰), TANG J (唐杰),ZHOU QH(周庆红).Research and development of male gametophyte of flowering Chinese cabbage microspore (菜心小孢子发生及雄配子体发育的研究)[J].Mod Gard(现代园艺),2013(3):7-9.

[19]CHENG YJ (程玉瑾),AI KF (艾珂飞),HUANG YQ (黄颖茜), et al. Plant regeneration of Brassica parachinensis cultured in vitro (菜心离体培养植株再生的研究)[J].J S China Agri Univ(Nat Sci)(华南农业大学学报:自然科学版),2002,23(4):89.

[20]ZHANG FL(张凤兰), KUGINUKI Y(钉贯靖久),YOSHIKAWA H (吉川宏昭).The influence of growth conditions of donor plants on the microspore culture in Chinese cabbage (环境条件对白菜小孢子培养的影响)[J]. Acta Agri Boreali-Sin(华北农学报),1994,9(1):95-100.